All practices

Practices · Pyrrhonist skepticism

Epochē

Suspending Judgement

Tradition
Pyrrhonist skepticism
Source
Sextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism I

Sextus Empiricus tells a story about the painter Apelles (Outlines of Pyrrhonism I.28–29). Apelles was painting a horse and wanted to show the foam at its mouth, and he failed again and again. In the end he gave up and threw the sponge he cleaned his brushes with at the picture. The mark it left looked like a horse's foam.

The Pyrrhonists said the same had happened to them. They had started philosophy hoping to find out which beliefs were true and so become calm. They couldn't decide, because every argument had an argument of equal force against it. So they suspended judgement, and calm followed the suspension, Sextus writes, as a shadow follows a body.

The suspension is called epochē, holding back. Sextus defines skepticism as an ability to set appearances and judgements against each other, so that their equal weight leads first to epochē and then to ataraxia, an untroubled mind (I.8). The Pyrrhonist doesn't deny that honey tastes sweet. He suspends judgement about whether honey is sweet in its nature, and goes on living by the appearances, by custom and by need.

The school goes back to Pyrrho of Elis, who lived around 360–270 BCE and wrote nothing. We know the method from Sextus, a physician of the second or third century CE.

How to practise it

Epochē works best on a belief that disturbs you: about the future, about another person's intentions, about what something means.

  1. Write down the belief as a plain statement. For example, “This pain means something serious”, or “He did it to hurt me”.
  2. Underneath, write the strongest case for it, in three or four lines.
  3. Then write the strongest case against it, as fairly as you can. The Pyrrhonists had standard ways to find one: ask how it would look to another person, at another time, in another state of mind.
  4. Read both. If you can't say in good faith which is stronger, say the Pyrrhonist phrase to yourself: “I determine nothing” (I.197), or “no more this than that”.
  5. Notice what happens in the body when you stop carrying the verdict. Then act on what is in front of you, as the Pyrrhonist does, by appearances and by need.
  6. Where a question is practical, such as whether to see a doctor, decide by the ordinary signs and by advice. Epochē is suspension of theory, and it never meant ignoring the appearances in front of you.

On toUnknown

toUnknown has no course in Pyrrhonism. The closest is Meditations by Marcus Aurelius, on the Stoic Path: twenty-five guided sittings on the notebook of the Stoic emperor. The Stoics argued with the skeptics for centuries, but they shared one discipline with them. Epictetus taught his students to tell a first impression, “You are only an impression, and not at all what you appear to be”, before giving it assent (Enchiridion 1). Marcus practised that pause every day, and the course is built on it.

The closest course on toUnknown

Meditations by Marcus Aurelius

The Stoic Path · €39 once, yours to keep — or included with membership at €11/month

Open the course

Questions people ask

What does epochē mean?

Epochē is Greek for holding back, or suspension. The Pyrrhonist skeptics used it for suspending judgement, neither affirming nor denying a belief about how things really are.

Who taught epochē?

Pyrrho of Elis, around 360–270 BCE, and later the Pyrrhonist school, whose methods survive in the Outlines of Pyrrhonism by Sextus Empiricus, written in the second or third century CE.

How is epochē different from the Stoic practice of assent?

The Stoics trained themselves not to assent to a first impression too quickly, but they held that some impressions deserve assent. The Pyrrhonists suspended judgement on every claim about the hidden nature of things.

All 25 practices · Pyrrhonist skepticism on nspire.you