All practices

Practices · Ignatian spirituality

Discernment

Reading Consolation and Desolation

Tradition
Ignatian spirituality
Source
Ignatius of Loyola, Spiritual Exercises (1548), §313–336

Ignatius of Loyola was a Basque soldier whose leg was shattered by a cannonball at Pamplona in 1521. During the long recovery he noticed something about his own daydreams. After dreaming of glory and a lady at court he felt dry and unsettled, and after dreaming of following the saints the peace stayed with him for a long time. That noticing became the core of his Spiritual Exercises, approved by the Pope in 1548.

Ignatius called the inner movements spirits and wrote rules for telling them apart, the discernment of spirits (§313–336). Two words carry the whole method. Consolation is any movement that kindles love, increases faith, hope and charity, and leaves you peaceful and drawn towards the good (§316). Desolation is the opposite: darkness, disquiet, restlessness, a pull towards low things, the feeling of being lukewarm and far from God (§317).

You can't choose which of the two you feel on a given day. What you can do is know which one you are in, and act accordingly. The best-known rule follows from that. In time of desolation, never make a change, but stay firm in the decision you made before it (§318). A decision taken in desolation comes from the desolation, and Ignatius trusted it least.

How to practise it

The daily examen, a short review of the day that Ignatius placed at the centre of the Exercises, is where discernment is learned. These steps follow its usual modern form.

  1. At the end of the day, sit quietly for ten to fifteen minutes. Ask for light to see the day as it was.
  2. Give thanks for what was good today, specifically: a conversation, a meal, a moment of quiet.
  3. Go back through the day hour by hour. Where did you feel consolation, drawn towards love and peace? Where did you feel desolation, restless, closed, cold?
  4. Look at what you did and chose in each of those moments, without condemning yourself.
  5. Ask for help where you went wrong, and look at tomorrow: one thing you will do differently.
  6. If a big decision is in front of you, write down in which state you are considering it. If it is desolation, wait.

After a few weeks of this, you will start to recognise the two states while you are in them, which is the point of the practice.

On toUnknown

toUnknown has no course in Ignatian spirituality. The closest is Unconditional Love, the Yoga of Liberation, on the Vedanta Path. Its opening talks are on viveka, discrimination between the real and the passing, and vairāgya, dispassion, and its guided sittings use the breath. It is the Indian counterpart of discernment: learning to tell apart what draws you towards freedom from what binds you.

The closest course on toUnknown

Unconditional Love — The Yoga of Liberation

The Vedanta Path · €39 once, yours to keep — or included with membership at €11/month

Open the course

Questions people ask

What is consolation in Ignatian spirituality?

Ignatius calls consolation any inner movement that kindles love of God, any increase of faith, hope and love, and any inner joy that draws you towards what is good (Spiritual Exercises §316).

What is desolation?

Darkness of soul, disquiet, a pull towards low things, restlessness and loss of hope, when you feel lukewarm, sad and separated from God (§317).

What is the main rule for decisions?

In time of desolation, never make a change. Keep to the decision you made before the desolation, or in the consolation that came before it (§318).

All 25 practices · Ignatian spirituality on nspire.you