learn · 2026-09-30 · 7 min read
Why do you go deeper on a retreat than in the city?
On the morning of the third of June 2024 I was sitting on a bench at Bangkok airport eating a melon that had travelled in my suitcase from India, and then I lay down on the same bench and slept. The two days before that I'd spent in a bright room at Seoul airport with a view of the road the buses leave by: I'd flown to Korea to volunteer at a Pa-Auk monastery, the woman at passport control didn't believe me, and I was handed a bun and a juice and not let into the country. In the end I bought my own ticket to Bangkok. In Bangkok I took a bunk in a hostel, spent a couple of days in the centre wondering what to do next, caught a cold from the air conditioners, was poisoned by a mushroom tom kha, and wrote to the Pa-Auk centre a hundred kilometres from the city that I'd been meaning to visit since 2022. They wrote back that there was a place. What I found there, in my experience, is that you go deeper on a retreat than in the city, for three reasons: an empty evening, a day with nothing to decide, and a sitting you don't get up from.
So four days later, tired, unslept, with a cold and after the poisoning, I arrived in thirty-five degrees of heat at Angthong and signed up for fifteen days of silence. For the first days I did nothing but recover. I lay down, I slept, I could barely make it from my room to the hall and the kitchen and back, and twice someone came running with a Covid test. We ate twice, at seven and at eleven, and the strength seemed to drain a little more each day; the mosquitoes took the nights, there was hardly any air to breathe, and somewhere around the sixth or seventh day I seriously thought about leaving. But I stayed until the twenty-first and bought a ticket for the twenty-second, back to India.

Thirteen days of the hardest retreat of my life gave more than a month of good sittings at home would have, and I spent a long time afterwards trying to understand why, because the place, frankly, was against me. It comes down to three things that any retreat has.
The first is the empty evening. After eleven there was no food, so by the evening sitting the stomach is empty, nothing is fermenting or being digested, everything slows down, and the body relaxes in a way it rarely does at home. That's half of it, and the other half is that nothing new comes in: no messages, no news, no films, no conversation. I wrote it down afterwards in plain words: because no content is consumed, no new emotions arise, and because no new emotions arise, the mind becomes calmer still. On an ordinary day we feed the mind all evening and then sit down and wonder why it's so loud.
The second is a day with nothing to decide. On a retreat every hour is taken: the bell gets you up, sits you down, feeds you, walks you and puts you to bed. Some days it feels like a prison where something changes every day and there's still no way out, and you catch yourself asking where freedom of choice went. But that's the design. A mind with nothing to decide has nothing to spend itself on, so it starts running the same film, the one I've watched retreat after retreat. First it shows family and friends, old scenes, a kind of nostalgia, then it builds plans, and then one day it's caught by a plain thought: and I'll be gone too? Everyone, every relationship, every event is temporary, and that's where compassion begins, for yourself and for everyone else; after it the thoughts thin out, and the ones that still come are given far less weight. The film needs unbroken days, and at home it's cut off every evening and starts from the beginning every morning.
The third is a sitting you don't get up from. On a ten-day Goenka course, from the fourth day, three sittings a day are sittings of strong determination: an hour in which you don't open the hands, the legs or the eyes. It's the most frightening rule of the course and the one that gives the most. At home, once the breath is steady, I go further: you move the attention from the breath to the surface of the body and then inside it, and on the day the scan goes inside, you sit for two hours, without moving and without uncrossing the legs, because that's the only way across the border between the outer and the inner, where you begin to feel the body from within. Pain comes first. You meet it with patience and will, not by shifting your legs. The long sitting is also a measure: if a person can sit two, three, four hours without a break, the body has become cleaner, the mind steady and unshakable, and after the sitting the body is fresh rather than tired. You can't get there in fifteen-minute pieces, and a retreat has the hours for it.
After Angthong I flew to India, and the next morning I was back in my own valley, Kullu, where a friend who sells fresh juice handed me a glass of pineapple with ginger, and I stayed for two months. From the window of my room on the third floor I could see the whole valley, and eagles flew past in the mornings. I got up at three, sat for two hours, went to bathe in the hot springs, bought five mangoes on the way back and met the sunrise on the balcony; around eleven I ate once more, fruit or a salad, then worked, and at six or seven in the evening sat again for two hours and went to bed. Some days I spent in complete darkness and silence, and for a month the depth held easily: I slept well, the ideas came, the discipline cost nothing.
At the start of the second month everything began to pall, the food, the routine, the work, and I started training again: running, the pull-up bar, now and then yoga. There was even more energy, but in the sitting I found what I now see every time I come back from a retreat into sport: more energy, less depth. After physical effort the body is different, and when I sat down the path I'd traced inside seemed blunted, and the work reached the mind through the body instead of directly. Neither is a mistake; they're different speeds. A retreat is for relaxing all the way in, and ordinary life is for movement, work and people, and the only mistake is an extreme, too much relaxation or too much tension.
So my advice depends on who's asking. Someone who has practised for years I'd tell to go away alone for five or ten days with no physical training and sit four to six hours a day: only then does the path become visible, and once you see it, the wish to go on comes by itself. For a beginner it's the other way round, meditation together with yoga, because in my experience the body clears faster with it, and the first weeks, when the legs go numb and you can't sit still, pass far more easily.
What can you take home? Not the silence and not that density of days, those need a closed gate. But more than people think. An early last meal: eat for the last time three or four hours before the evening sitting and notice the difference in the sitting, not on the scales. An evening without content, one a week: nothing new in, no screen after sunset, and see how much quieter the mind is when it hasn't been fed. A day decided in advance, with fixed times written down the night before, is the part of a retreat that's easiest to carry home, and I wrote about it in the note on half past four. And one long sitting a week in which you don't move: start with an hour, and the two hours will come on their own when the body and the mind are ready for them.
None of it replaces a retreat, but with it you arrive at the next one with something to go deep from, and that's what the home course is built on (retreat and home, honestly). And in the Kullu valley that summer I stopped watching films and listening to music altogether: the life around me had become the film.
Questions people ask
Why can a retreat go deeper than a month at home?
Ocean DYNN names three things any retreat has: an empty evening, which at Angthong meant no food after eleven and no new content coming in; a day with nothing to decide; and a long sitting in which you don't move.
What can you take home from a retreat?
An early last meal, three or four hours before the evening sitting; one evening a week without content; a day decided in advance with fixed times written the night before; and one long sitting a week in which you don't move, starting with an hour.
Does exercise change the depth of a sitting?
In his experience, yes. After training he found more energy but less depth, because the work reached the mind through the body. He calls them different speeds, and the only mistake an extreme.
Does a beginner need a retreat?
Ocean DYNN would tell a long-time practitioner to go away alone for five or ten days with no physical training. For a beginner it is the other way round: meditation together with yoga, because in his experience the body clears faster.
Start Vipassana Part 1More from Learn


