Learn

learn · 2026-09-12 · 6 min read

Where Marcus Aurelius agrees with Vipassana, and where he doesn't

By Ocean DYNN · published 2026-09-12 · updated 2026-10-31 · Читать по-русски

At Dhamma Mahi in France, in 2013, after ten days of serving in the kitchen, I let my Cambodian neighbour talk me into staying for ten more as a student, because I had nowhere to go and nothing to get there on. The hours in the hall brought an enormous pain in my legs, and all I could do was go on sitting, smiling, without reacting to the hurricane inside. The same situation is in a notebook written by a Roman emperor: "If thou art pained by any external thing, it is not this thing that disturbs thee, but thy own judgment about it" (VIII, 47, in George Long's translation). Read with a Vipassana-trained mind, he agrees with the meditator almost everywhere, and parts company only on method.

Marcus Aurelius wrote the Meditations for nobody. They're a notebook, an emperor talking to himself at night, on campaign, while running an empire and losing people he loved, and one of its books ends with a note of where he was, "Among the Quadi at the Granua", and another with "This in Carnuntum". They were never meant to be read, and that's what makes them usable, because there's no argument in them to win, only a man trying, over and over, to see clearly.

Watch · Marcus Aurelius 15 Min. Guided Meditation - THE INNER CITADEL - Stoicism meditations · 15 min · from the toUnknown YouTube channel · on its own page

I turned twenty-five of his themes into a course of guided meditations, and for each there's a short talk on what he wrote and why, then a fifteen-minute guided sitting on it. More than two thousand people have started it on Insight Timer. One of them wrote afterwards that it had inspired them to read the Meditations themselves, which is the best outcome I could have asked for, and another that each day gave her a place to organise her thoughts and begin with intention, which is almost exactly what Marcus was using the notebook for.

Reading him with a Vipassana-trained mind, I kept finding two things: agreement so close it was startling, and one difference that doesn't go away.

Where they agree

Impermanence comes first, because the first sitting I ever recorded on Marcus was on this, before I had a course. He comes back to it again and again: everything you see is already passing, the person who praises you and the person you fear will be forgotten, and so will you. The Vipassana tradition calls this anicca, and it's the first of the three characteristics a meditator is taught to observe in every sensation, which arises, changes and passes. Marcus reached it by reflection and the meditator by watching a sensation on the skin for an hour, and they arrive at the same place, except that the Stoic writes it down to remember it in the morning, and the meditator doesn't need to, because the body keeps demonstrating it.

Then there's the present moment. Marcus tells himself that the only thing anyone can be deprived of is the present, because it's the only thing anyone has. That's the first sitting of the course, and it's the first instruction of ānāpānasati, attention to the breath: this breath, not the last one and not the next. The two traditions aren't borrowing from each other here, they just noticed the same fact.

Acceptance is the one I met in my legs. His image of a fortress inside, which no external event can breach, is the Stoic version of equanimity, the quality Vipassana is aimed at producing and the one the whole method of observe, don't react is built to train. When he writes that sentence about judgement, a meditator recognises the instruction exactly: the pain in the knee is a sensation, and the suffering is the reaction, so you watch the sensation and drop the reaction. He'd have been a good student.

Discipline agrees too, and so does the morning. "I am rising to the work of a human being," the Stoic tells himself when he gets up unwillingly, and the meditator sits at the fixed time whether the mind is willing or not, and both know that the decision made once, in advance, is the only one that holds.

And there's interconnectedness. Marcus, who had every reason to think himself separate from everyone, kept writing that he was a limb of one body, and that what harms the hive harms the bee. The Buddhist word is mettā, loving-kindness, and it's practised rather than argued, but the conclusion is the same, and both men would have said it was a description, not a wish.

Where they don't

The difference is the method, and it isn't small.

Marcus reasons, and the Stoic practice is cognitive: you examine the judgement, correct it and replace the false impression with the true one. The mind governs itself by argument, and the Meditations are that argument, repeated because it doesn't stay corrected. It works, as readers have been saying for centuries, but it works at the level of thought, using thought.

Vipassana doesn't reason. It goes underneath the judgement to the sensation the judgement was built on, and observes that. On that cushion in France I wasn't telling myself that pain isn't an evil; a meditator with a pain in the knee watches it arise and change and pass, and the judgement never gets made, so the reaction doesn't need correcting, because it isn't produced. That's a different place to stand, and it's why a Vipassana practitioner reading Marcus keeps thinking: yes, and you could have stopped one step earlier.

The second difference follows from the first. The Stoic keeps a self who governs: the ruling faculty, the inner citadel, the I that judges well or badly. The Buddhist practice, followed all the way, finds no such governor, because anattā, not-self, is the third characteristic, and it's observed, not decided. Marcus builds the citadel and then lives in it, and the meditator watches the citadel and finds it's also passing. They agree about almost everything a person should do, and what they disagree about is who is doing it, which is the same disagreement I had to sit through myself, between the Vipassana I was trained in and the self-inquiry I came to later.

I teach him anyway, because the agreement is the useful part, and because Marcus is a door that many people can walk through who would never walk through a Pali word. A person who's never sat can read that the present is the only thing they can lose and feel it land, and fifteen minutes of guided sitting after that talk is the same fifteen minutes of breath they'd get on the Vipassana Path, except that they've come by a different road, one built in their own civilisation.

One student, in an honest four-star review, said she wasn't sure the talk and the sitting needed to be on separate days, and combined them. She was right for herself, and you're free to do that on the course, but the separation was a choice: Marcus wrote at night and lived the idea the next day, and the course keeps that rhythm of hearing it, sleeping on it and sitting with it. It opens with a one-minute introduction, a five-minute talk on the present moment and a fifteen-minute sitting, and those three tracks are open to anyone.

Questions people ask

What do Marcus Aurelius and Vipassana agree on?

Impermanence, the present moment, acceptance of what happens, discipline and interconnectedness. Marcus reached them by reflection; a meditator watches the body show them, sensation by sensation.

How does Stoicism differ from Vipassana meditation?

The Stoic corrects a judgement by reasoning. Vipassana goes under the judgement to the sensation it was built on and observes that, so the reaction isn't produced. The Stoic also keeps a governing self; Vipassana, followed all the way, finds none.

Is there a guided meditation course on Marcus Aurelius?

Yes. Twenty-five of his themes, each with a short talk on what he wrote and a fifteen-minute guided sitting, on Insight Timer and tounknown.com. The first three tracks are open to anyone.

Start Marcus AureliusMore from Learn

Keep reading