learn · 2026-09-28 · 5 min read
What is meditation at Wat Chomthong like, and why did I leave?
I didn't come to Wat Chomthong by plan. Two nights earlier, on my birthday, a rickshaw had taken me down back roads to the Pa-Auk centre near Mandalay, and a small man there told us that because of the situation in the country the centre was closed. Within a couple of hours I'd found another centre, in Thailand this time, and bought a ticket. A day after that I was standing at a gate near Chiang Mai, where the first thing they did was hand me white clothes, show me a room, give me a timer and teach me to bow. Every retreat I'd sat before that was in one of two traditions, S.N. Goenka's or Pa-Auk Sayadaw's, and this was a third, the Mahasi tradition. I'd never bowed to anyone in my life and didn't understand why anyone would. I stayed three days: the day is made of movements noted one by one, with a timer and assistants who may knock at any hour, and that week I wanted silence, so I left. How I got there, from the closed monastery to that gate, I've told in a note on vipassana.life about three days in the Mahasi tradition; this is what I learned there, why it's probably the best format there is for a beginner, and why it was the wrong place for me that particular week.
The centre teaches satipaṭṭhāna, the four foundations of mindfulness, and works almost entirely on the first of them, the body. Where a Goenka course keeps you on a cushion with your eyes shut for ten hours, here the day is made of movements noted as they happen. Walking: the right foot goes like this, the left foot goes like that, and you know each step at the moment it's taken. Sitting: not the breath at the nostrils but the belly, rising and falling, rising and falling, each movement noted as it arises. There are four main postures, standing, walking, sitting and lying, and the small movements between them, bending, reaching, turning, lifting, letting go, and you note those too. And before all of it comes the bow, done slowly, kneeling, palms on the thighs, the men on their heels, each movement of the hands and the body watched and named to yourself.

The assistants were there all day. They could knock on the door of your hut at any hour to ask how the practice was going, show you the bows again, sit with you and go through it. For a beginner that's ideal, because it's the opposite of being left alone with an instruction: someone checks, corrects and encourages, and you can go to them, you're meant to go to them, whenever something is unclear. On the first morning breakfast was rice in water with raw ginger grated thinly over it, and for anything else you were allowed to walk to the nearest market, which I did every morning and every lunchtime for all three days.
Why I left
Because my mind was restless and wanted the thing I already knew. By the time I came to Wat Chomthong I had more than ten years of sitting behind me, and even the ten-day satipaṭṭhāna course I'd sat in Cambodia years before, after two or three years of hard sitting, had felt at the time like the most serious thing I'd done. What I wanted that week was to go inward again, close my eyes and be quiet, to be on my own the way you are on a Goenka course. What the centre had was walking with my eyes open and a knock on the door. The knock was kindly meant, and for a first-timer it's exactly right, and to me it was an interruption. I found I wasn't interested, and I've learned to trust that: a mind that isn't interested in the method in front of it doesn't practise it, whatever it tells itself. I needed the silence of a sitting retreat, and I found it at the Pa-Auk centre on Batam, where I sat fifteen days that same month.
That isn't a judgement of the centre. It's the most useful thing the three days taught me: a practice has to match the state of the person arriving. A restless mind can't practise anything, which is why my own home course spends a month on the breath before the body, and a mind that years of sitting have already quietened isn't helped by being taught, again, how to walk. The same method is right for one person and wrong for another on the same day.
The bows I kept. I learned them from two Russian volunteers, who explained not only how but to whom. You bow to the Buddha for the teaching, because he handed it on to us; you bow to the Sangha, the whole community of those who practise, because it exists and because it holds you up; and you bow to the Dhamma, meaning the truth, the laws of the world, the laws of nature, the principles of ethics. I had thought bowing was submission to a person. It isn't, and once I understood who it was for, I could do it.
I kept the four foundations too, and I now explain them on my own course, because a beginner should know the whole map even while walking one road. The first foundation, the body, is where most people should start, because the body is coarse enough to notice. The second, feeling, pleasant, unpleasant or neutral, is deeper work that needs more effort and more time. The third, mind, meaning the states of consciousness themselves, is further in again. The fourth, mental qualities and processes: memory, perception, the hindrances, the factors of awakening, the four truths, the path. Each is subtler than the one before and each needs the one before it to be steady; the Buddha's discourse gives all four, and every tradition I've sat in chooses for itself where on that ladder to put a beginner's foot.
If you've never sat and you can get to a centre like Wat Chomthong, go: the walking, the noting, the bows and the knock on the door will slow you down until you can see your own mind moving, and you'll have a human being to ask. If you've sat for years and want to go deeper, choose the silence. And if you're practising at home with a recording, know that it's closer to the second than the first, because nobody will knock. That's why so much in the first days of the home course depends on you, and why the first three tracks of every course are open to anyone: so you can find out which kind of practitioner you are before you promise yourself anything bigger. I stayed on for a couple of days after my three in the little town by the monastery, in a wooden house of a kind I'd never seen in Thailand before, slept wonderfully, and then flew to Batam.
Questions people ask
What tradition does Wat Chomthong teach?
The Mahasi tradition: satipaṭṭhāna, the four foundations of mindfulness, worked almost entirely through the body, with walking, the rising and falling belly and every small movement noted as it happens.
Is Wat Chomthong good for a beginner?
Yes, probably the best format there is: assistants check, correct and encourage, and you can go to them whenever something is unclear, instead of being left alone with an instruction.
Why did you leave Wat Chomthong after three days?
My mind was restless and wanted the silence of a sitting retreat with eyes closed, not walking with eyes open and a knock on the door. I went on to the Pa-Auk centre on Batam and sat fifteen days.
Who do you bow to at a Mahasi centre?
To the Buddha for the teaching, to the Sangha, the community of those who practise, and to the Dhamma, the truth and the laws of nature. It isn't submission to a person.
Start Vipassana Part 1More from Learn


